The Sin Bin Fiasco: When Rules Reign Supreme Over Reason The NRL finals match between Penrith and Roosters was marred by controversy when Nathan Cleary was sent to the sin bin for a high tackle on Hugo Savala.
At first glance, it seemed like another example of referees making tough calls in high pressure situations. However, closer inspection reveals that the rules may be being applied with too much zeal.
Cleary's tackle was deemed reckless and posed a significant risk to Savala's safety. While contact with the kicker is a gray area, this particular incident seems to have been blown out of proportion.